Woods vs. Nicklaus. Lakers vs. Celtics. Yankees vs. Red Sox. Bentgrass vs. bermudagrass. Yes, great sports debates can carry over to the greens of your favorite golf course.
For many people on a Myrtle Beach golf trip, the bent vs. bermuda debate most closely resembled the Yankees-Red Sox rivalry. The Yankees (representing bentgrass) had the championships and history to back their position, while the Red Sox (bermuda grass) had supporters but there was little doubt about the superior product.
Just as the Red Sox have turned their blood feud with the Yankees on its head in recent years, bermuda, too, has made significant inroads in challenging the king's throne.
Historically bentgrass has provided the game's best putting surface. It's a strain of grass that grows upright, allowing golfers to putt on its tips, which promotes the smoothest roll. Combine the upright growth with the ability of bentgrass to withstand a close shave and it often produces the game's fastest, truest putting surface.
Conversely, bermuda tended to lay prostrate, which led to a "grainy" putting surface. When golfers putted into the grain the ball was prone to jump and break more. When putting with the grain, ball speed increased while break decreased. A golfer unaccustomed to bermuda was subject to struggle getting adjusted.
But just as science and technology have produced medical breakthroughs in fields like stem cell research and gene therapy, some of the same methods have been used to create hybrid bermuda grasses like Champion, Tifdwarf and MiniVerde. Those advances have significantly enhanced the quality of bermuda greens.
"We've been able to create conditions across all grasses that are more uniform," Dave Downing, a partner at Signature Golf Group and the president of the Golf Course Superintendents Association of America, said. "I think in today's world you can transfer your game from one grass to another and most players will not know (the difference)."
The new strains of bermuda grow more upright and can be cut as low as an 1/8th of an inch, virtually eliminating problems with grain. The MiniVerde, recently installed at TPC of Myrtle Beach, SouthCreek at Myrtle Beach National and Eagle Nest, has the hardiest root structure of the new grasses, making it a popular choice.
"We choose MiniVerde because of increased rooting and we have some shade," said Michael Bankert, the golf course superintendent at Myrtle Beach National who oversaw the installation of MiniVerde at South Creek. "Right now (the new greens) are spectacular, very smooth, no grain and they aren't scalping at all."
"MiniVerde is pretty darned similar to penncross bentgrass," said Downing. "Penncross is still the dominant variety throughout all the Northeast. It's kind of the standard which all bentgrasses are measured. I think (MiniVerde) has gotten were its very, very comparable to bentgrass."
While the scientific advances and the fact that bermuda is a warm season grass, meaning it thrives during the Myrtle Beach summer, has allowed it to narrow the gap, bentgrass remains very popular. The newer strands of bent - L93 and A1 - offer a smoother roll than their predecessors and increased durability. (click for a list of Grand Strand courses with bentgrass greens)
While the debate today is whether bent or bermuda is the best grass for the Myrtle Beach golf market, other challengers are beginning to emerge.
Pas Palum, the grass that will cover Pine Lakes International Country Club from tee to green, thrives in sodium heavy water and warm temperatures. There is every reason to believe Pas Palum's popularity along the Grand Strand will continue to grow.
The winners in this evolving rivalry are golfers, who are being rewarded with a more durable and better putting surface on an annual basis.
I am glad to see greens being addressed in your article. You failed to mention winter overseed, a playing condition that is common for a year round destination like Myrtle Beach.
Our group tries to avoid playing too many bermuda greens on our annual winter trip. Yes improvements have been made, but there is still a significant difference between playing on bent vs bermuda (or overseed rye) in the winter.
PS Aberdeen should be on your bent list.
My bad Aberdeen has bermuda greens.
Brian,
We no longer over seed greens with Ryegrass, we switched to a much finer textured grass several years ago and putting greens in the winter and spring are really good not just because of the variety of the grass but the management we as golf course superintendents apply to the surfaces. The real deal is that while the grasses have been improving so have our management techniques to create uniform conditions 12 months out of the year!
Dave